Psalms come in different shapes as well as sizes
If you want your congregation to join in, it’s very important that they feel comfortable with what’s going on. If they don’t, they will keep quiet and just watch everyone else. We long for the days when we can encourage a congregation to join in the singing again, so when the restrictions are lifted, we want everyone to feel ready to take part with confidence. This means understanding what is going on; and part of this is knowing what shape the Responsorial Psalm is for this week,
– because the Responsorial Psalm can take different forms. I’ve written before about psalm-lullabies, but at least they usually follow the standard shape. Some of the other types change even the format. Most often we have the verse + chorus model, with which everyone is familiar from folk songs and Christmas carols. The verses change but the chorus stays the same, so even those who didn’t know it at the beginning can pick it up and join in freely by the end.
Other liturgies which use the psalms (like the Anglican tradition) sing the psalms straight through without a Response or Chorus. This is beautiful, covers the Psalter more efficiently and is easier to control and practise, but you don’t get the congregation joining in. Sometimes the choir divides, just as in the cathedral tradition (Decani, the side where the Dean sits, and Cantoris, the other side, for the Cantor), so that the verses of the psalms can alternate; again, no audience participation, but difference in the way it feels and sounds. Think of it like mediaeval stereo, with the sound coming from alternating speakers, or as God’s Dolby helicopter in a film’s opening.
Psalm as psea pshanty
There are a few psalms (and a couple of canticles) where the poetic form is like a sea shanty. I’ve talked about this before, specifically about the Daniel canticle. Sea shanties are currently having a moment, as part of the pandemic, though I am not at all sure why. Perhaps it’s because, if you’re rehearsing on Zoom, it’s a lot easier to keep together when the lines are short, and anyway, with shanties, a bit of rough-and-ready is already factored in.
In a religious context we tend to call them litanies rather than shanties, but the principle is the same. One person (or less often, a group) says or sings a line of text, which varies every time but has something to keep them together. They might be titles for Our Lady : ‘Rose of Sharon’, ‘Tower of David’, ‘Star of the sea’ etc. After each brief line, another person (or usually group) answers with their own line, which keeps repeating: ‘Pray for us’, or ‘Alleluia’, or ‘Have mercy on us’, but the pattern is that the first halves change all the time and the second half doesn’t. I used this sort of shape in the Mayfield Mass Kyrie, so that the congregation can ease into singing it after learning just one simple line of melody. The Agnus Dei inverts this, using the same first half three times, and changing the second half. It seems to work well, and is easy to pick up.
Verse and chorus
One of the things which first attracted me to writing tunes for psalms is the shape of the Responsorial Psalm as we Catholics sing it Sunday by Sunday, with verse and chorus, like so many traditional folk songs or nursery rhymes. Children learn how they work just as they learn turn-taking in speech. I say this; you answer that. Some of the oldest forms of tonguetwister and word games work the same way (I am a gold lock…I am a gold key, and so on). Some of our earliest musical memories are probably this shape; such songs are easy to pick up and join in with. They encourage everyone to take part.
Shapes in the Psalter
If the Book of Psalms is the Church’s first hymn book, it’s a hymn book designed to encourage audience participation, with its repetition and simple shapes. It’s fascinating to see the shapes already there in the written text of the Book of Psalms, from litanies (Pss 117/118, 134/135) to songs with choruses (Pss 45/46, 48/49, 66/67). We can see the shapes of some psalms more clearly than others. Sometimes a chorus is used to give shape to what might otherwise be a bit unwieldy (Ps 79/80, for example). I think it’s quite likely that some of the psalms, where there is a short first stanza before the psalm takes a breath and sets off, might well have been sung as we shape them today, as Responsorial Psalms, with that first piece being the recurring Response (see Pss 19/20, 83/84 and 127/128, as well as the several which just start ‘Alleluia’). In Psalm 106/107, this possible suggested response even comes in quotation marks. I’m not sure at what stage of translation or editing they would have been added (this is, after all, a very ancient, very foreign text, however familiar), but I think they indicate something about the way that psalm has been shaped and used, as well as the other psalms where similar phrases occur.
Shaping the Response as well as the psalm
The only slight problem here is that sometimes the Responses we have prescribed for us in the Lectionary can feel too short. This didn’t matter in the old days, when church musicians were allowed to repeat something (imagine saying to any church musician of previous centuries that they couldn’t repeat an Alleluia or a Dona nobis pacem), but nowadays this is officially frowned upon and some Responses feel too short to balance the verse length. I have talked about this before. And sometimes a Response is just bad (see my complaints about this here).
Sailors and marines
Litanies are even easier than the standard Responsorial Psalm (because there is less to remember), but the group/congregation/team has to work harder, as they are holding up half of the song. They are also less familiar as a shape for the psalm, so it really is worth explaining before Mass what the shape is, if it’s not the standard verse+chorus. So long as enough people are not taken by surprise, the latecomers will catch up. Every line (or pair of lines) in a litany/shanty alternates between the singers, and everyone has to stay alert (this is why they are good work songs). An older form of sea shanty is called ‘chanty’, which is of course a reference to its heritage from Gregorian chant. No, there I am kidding, but certainly some sea shanties are old, and Phoenician sailors were probably using similar songs to help keep time hauling up an anchor even long before Peter and Andrew were boys learning to fish in Galilee with their father. A modern version is US Marines singing as they do their morning runs.
All together now
It’s not about beautiful singing or developed melody; it’s all about rhythm and keeping together. Think about the man on the drums to keep the rowers together on the ship in Ben Hur. They have to have a Hortator (the man doing the drumming, same root as ‘to exhort’) to set the rhythm because they are working so hard they have no breath to sing (and they are slaves from all over the Roman Empire, so they wouldn’t have come from a shared musical tradition). With a free crew singing a normal sea shanty, the men are working but not at full stretch, so they can sing at least enough to make the responses. And the shantyman can improvise and/or make jokes, so long as he keeps to the rhythm, which also keeps the crew listening attentively (just like the Marines). This is not a technique open to us with our Sunday psalms, however.
Making it clear and keeping it simple
Anything can work, so long as the people singing and listening know what the form is. The usual shape of our Sunday psalms is verse + chorus, and most people are used to that. The number of verses can vary, the length of the verses can vary, but so long as the movement into the Response is clear and remains the same throughout, you can get away with a surprising amount of variation. There are even psalms (e.g. Ps 30/31 for Good Friday) where I have needed to use two tunes alternating (though always keeping the same Response), and it’s been fine. Confidence (yours as well as theirs) is crucial. Explain at the beginning if you need to, give a clear lead and offer plenty of eye contact. At the moment, this all feels slightly academic, as our congregations are tiny and behind face masks, but we can nurture the will to sing, and better times are coming.
© Kate Keefe and Music for Mass 2021 Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Kate Keefe and Music for Mass with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.